Common Running Injuries (No.2)... 'Runner's knee'

Patella Femoral Joint Pain (discomfort at the front of the knee), also known as 'Runner's Knee', is one of the most common problems reported by the running community. It often occurs with a gradual onset with no obvious cause of injury or trauma. It can be a very frustrating problem as it can appear to settle down with rest/treatment; however it can quickly re-occur when attempting a return to running.
To manage Patella Femoral Pain and prevent a re-occurrence of the discomfort the following steps below are a good guide...
Reduce the pain
Address contributing/aggravating factors
Gradual increase of the Patella femoral joint’s work load tolerance
How do I reduce the pain??
As a runner myself it’s quite hard to say this but initially running would be advised to be modified/reduced or even stopped to reduce the Patella Femoral joint (knee cap) load allowing the symptoms to settle. After the initial groans of disappointment I can hear you asking... 'how do I know what is still too much??' Unfortunately there is no easy answer, as it is not always black and white. Although, as previously discussed in the Plantar Heel Pain blog, a good way to judge whether or not we should still run is by following a traffic light system using a pain scale of 0-10. If your pain is 0-3 this is classed as a safe zone and a green light to continue running. If it’s 4-5 this is amber and classed as acceptable to run but caution is required. However if it’s 6-10 then unfortunately, this is a red light and classed as excessive and having a break from running would be advised until the pain settles. Therefore mild pain is ok providing the discomfort eases within 24 hours of the activity and isn’t worse after this period.
If running does have to stop/be reduced for a short while non aggravating cross training activities such as cycling and swimming to maintain fitness is highly recommended. There are also other various ways to help manage and reduce the pain initially with ice/analgesia (Non-Steroidal Anti-inflammatories), soft tissue massage, joint/patella mobilisations and taping. However unfortunately with anterior knee pain these are only affective as useful adjuncts often only providing short term benefits if the underlying problems are not addressed.
What contributing factors might need addressing?
A review by Lankhorst et al (2013) established there could be up to as many as 500 contributing factors to Patella femoral joint pain! Highlighting the complex nature of the condition. However, although it has been suggested there could be up to 500 different contributing factors, the list below is often the most common areas which may need some attention...
Quadriceps, Gluteal, Hamstring & Gastroc/Soleus strength
Altered movement control E.g. Increased hip adduction (knee dipping inwards) and knee flexion (too much knee bend) during running gait
Reduced flexibility of Quadriceps/Hamstrings/Gluteal Maximus/Tensor Fascia Lata/Gastroc/Soleus and hip flexors
Reduced joint range of movement E.g. Ankle dorsiflexion (foot moving upwards)
Recent sudden increase/change in activity/work load (very common with runners and often the main cause... 'too much too soon'... E.g miles/hill work/speed work)
Gradually increasing the Patella femoral joints work load...

Alongside addressing the above factors a gradual return to running can begin once discomfort has settled (again following the above mentioned traffic light system).
When running our knees require to be able to tolerate up to 7-8 times our body weight. So for a return to running with no problems we need a gradual phased return alongside exercise which is graded towards improving the load tolerance of the Patella Femoral joint. By doing this it reduces the risk of further setbacks through making the knee more robust and able to manage the potential 7-8 times body weight stresses being placed upon it when running.
Knowing what is a low load exercise and how to build this to the high demands of running is the trick. For example... Carrying out a static squat (0-90 degrees knee bend) would be a lower load exercise than a single leg knee dip. However occasionally a static squat would be initially too irritable therefore reducing the squat to 0-50 degrees knee bend (shallow squat) would be carried out to reduce the knee load further (as a deeper knee bend places more stress through the Patella Femoral Joint). So in essence the overall aim is to strengthen without aggravating the problem.
Below are an example of exercises to address the above points and lead towards improving the Patella Femoral Joint's load tolerance. When carrying out the below exercises it is again important to follow the above traffic light system for pain response. Repetitions and sets can be adapted in relation to this. For example if you are aiming for 3 sets of 10 of an exercise and the pain initially is 3 out of 10 but then rises to 6 during your 3rd set of 10 exercises you should stop at this point, as the discomfort has risen beyond the amber zone of 5 into the red zone of 6-10. Continuing the exercise at this point would most likely aggravate the problem rather than help improve it. In addition, it’s recommended you only carry out the exercises every other day to allow recovery and adaptation for improvement to occur. Load management is key!
Exercises…
With physiotherapy there are evidenced based/researched treatments but it’s good to remember we are all different and often there is no one size fits all approach. So when carrying out the exercises you may have to adapt the amount (following the traffic light system) or maybe not carry out the particular exercise if it is too aggravating at this point of your recovery. A good guide to follow (which can be adapted according to symptom response) is to aim for 3-4 exercises, 3 sets of 8-12 for each, 2-3 times a week.
- Side lying resisted hip abduction:
- Seated resisted knee extension: (Initially 90-45 degrees knee bend as lower stress to Patella)
- Seated resisted knee extension: (90-0 degrees knee bend - progress to if no problems with 90-45 degrees as above)
- Squat: (Initially 0-50 degrees knee bend as lower stress to Patella) - If no problems progress to deeper squat (0-90 degrees as also shown). If no problems with 0-90 degrees squat, adding resistance by holding dumbbells/bar can be considered, as the overall aim of rehabilitation is to increase the Patella Femoral joints load capacity to accept the stresses of running.
- Step up with raise of opposite knee: (Exercise loads the knee and also challenges hip control)
- Step up with raise of opposite knee holding dumbbell in opposite hand: (Progress to if no problems with above step up: Increases Patella Femoral joint load further and also increases the challenge to sustain hip control)
- Single leg knee dip:
End stage/later stage rehabilitation (Can begin below if no problems with above group of exercises)
- Double foot jump off step and land:
- Single leg hop off step and land: (Progress to if no problems with double foot jump and land)
Although anterior knee pain is often related to the discussed Patella Femoral joint, it is also worth bearing in mind there can be other sources of the symptoms. A selection of these include: Ilio-tibial band, synovial plica, Patella tendon, Quadriceps tendon, fat pad and bursa. Also to make things just a little bit more complicated it can often be a combination and not just one of these alone! Therefore if your symptoms aren't resolving, seeking a thorough assessment from a health professional would be advised.
Hope this helps! If you have any questions please get in touch!
*The above information is not designed to replace medical advice. If you have an injury it is recommended to see a health professional for assessment and diagnosis.




Comments